CoMeal › Guides › Couples & families

Picky eaters: how to stop cooking separate meals for your child

By CoMeal · Updated · 7 min read

The short answer

Cook one family meal and serve it in parts, so a picky eater can choose what goes on their plate. Always include one safe food they usually eat, offer small tastes of the rest with no pressure, and let them serve themselves. You decide what is served and when; your child decides whether to eat and how much.

Making pasta for one child, nuggets for another and something else for the adults is exhausting. This guide shows how to cook one dinner that a fussy eater can still manage, without bribes, battles or a second pan. You will get a simple method, a table of meals that come apart well, and a worked example for a family of four.

How do you stop cooking separate meals for a picky eater?

Cook one meal, serve it in parts, and make sure there is always one food on the table your child usually eats. That way nobody needs a separate dinner, and your child is never left hungry or cornered.

Most family meals split into a base, a protein, a vegetable and a sauce. Keep those parts apart on the table or on the child's plate, and the same pot feeds everyone. Start with one or two dinners a week done this way, then build from there.

What is the division of responsibility in feeding?

It is a widely used feeding approach: the adult decides what food is offered, when and where; the child decides whether to eat it and how much. Each side sticks to its own job.

In practice you choose the dinner and set the time, and then you stop. No "three more bites", no deals about pudding. If your child eats only the rice tonight, that is their call, and the next meal or snack comes at the usual time. The menu stays yours, so you stop being a short-order cook.

How do you serve one meal deconstructed?

Serve the parts of the dish separately so each person builds their own plate. The adults can mix everything together; a picky eater can take the plain pasta and a few pieces of chicken and leave the sauce.

A few ways to do it:

  • Put components in bowls in the middle of the table, family style.
  • Set aside a portion of plain protein before you add sauce or spices.
  • Keep sauce in a jug so it is added at the table, not in the pan.
  • Serve raw versions of the vegetables in the dish, such as cucumber or grated carrot, alongside the cooked ones. For young children, grate or thinly slice hard raw vegetables to lower the risk of choking.
  • Use a plate with sections if mixed foods on a plate upset your child.

For more ideas on splitting one dinner for different needs, see our guide to cooking once and serving different plates.

Which family meals work best for picky eaters?

Meals that are built from separate parts work best: tacos, pasta, rice bowls, roast dinners and anything with a sauce that can be held back. Avoid dishes where everything is cooked together, like a curry or a stew, until your child is more relaxed about mixed foods, or keep some parts plain before they go in.

MealHow it comes apartSafe food to include
Tacos or fajitasMince or chicken, tortillas, cheese, lettuce, salsa in separate bowlsPlain tortillas and grated cheese
Spaghetti bolognesePlain pasta, sauce on the side, grated cheesePlain buttered pasta
Roast chicken dinnerChicken, potatoes, carrots, peas and gravy all served separatelyRoast potatoes
Stir-fryCook noodles and plain chicken first, add sauce and veg for adultsPlain noodles
Homemade pizzaEveryone tops their own baseCheese and tomato
Jacket potatoesFillings in bowls: beans, cheese, tuna mayo, coleslawPotato with butter or cheese
Fish, chips and peasOven chips, fish fillet, peas and sauce kept apartChips
Rice bowlsRice, protein, sweetcorn, cucumber, sauce on the sidePlain rice

Why include a safe food at every meal?

A safe food is something your child reliably eats, such as bread, rice, pasta, potatoes or a familiar fruit. Putting one on the table at every meal means your child can always eat something, which lowers the stakes and makes them more willing to sit at the table with new foods.

The safe food should be part of the family meal, not a separate dinner: plain rice next to the chilli, or bread with soup. Everyone can have some.

How do you get a picky eater to try new foods without pressure?

Offer very small amounts, often, and then say nothing about it. Many children need to see and handle a food many times before they will taste it, so a single pea or one slice of pepper on the plate is a reasonable start.

Things that tend to help:

  1. Put a tiny amount of the new food on their plate, or let them take it themselves.
  2. Eat it yourself and enjoy it, without commentary.
  3. Let them touch, smell, lick or spit it out into a napkin. That still counts as contact.
  4. Offer the same food again on another day, cooked the same way or slightly differently.
  5. Keep the conversation about anything other than the food.

Letting children serve themselves from bowls on the table gives them some control, which often makes them braver.

How can children help plan and cook family meals?

Involve them before the food reaches the table. Children are more likely to try a dish they chose, washed, stirred or helped plan.

Let them pick one dinner from two or three options when you plan the week, or choose a vegetable at the supermarket. At home, give them simple jobs such as washing potatoes, grating cheese or stirring a sauce, and supervise around knives and heat.

If you plan your week once, on the same day, this becomes easy to fit in. Our weekly meal planning routine for beginners suggests planning four or five dinners, not seven, which leaves room for leftovers and nights off. An app like CoMeal can help here: each person sets the foods they won't eat, and CoMeal plans one shared meal with simple swaps on each person's plate.

Worked example: a family of four and one dinner

Here is how one dinner can work for a whole household without a second pan.

The family: two adults who eat everything, Maya (9) who will try most things, and Sam (5) who mainly eats pasta, bread, cheese, apples and plain chicken.

Tonight's dinner: chicken and vegetable pasta bake.

  1. Cook the pasta and set a small bowl of it aside, plain, with a little butter.
  2. Pan-fry the chicken until cooked through, with no pink in the middle, and set a few plain pieces aside before adding garlic and herbs.
  3. Make the tomato and vegetable sauce, mix with the rest of the pasta and chicken, top with cheese and bake.
  4. On the table: the pasta bake, the bowl of plain pasta, plain chicken, grated cheese and a plate of sliced apple and cucumber.

The adults and Maya eat the bake. Sam takes plain pasta, cheese and chicken, with one spoonful of the bake on the side and no comment. Everyone ate the same dinner and nobody cooked twice.

If the adults also have different diets or goals, our guide to planning family meals when everyone eats differently shows how to fit those in as well.

When should you worry about a picky eater?

Most fussy eating in young children is a normal phase, but some signs need a professional's view. Talk to your GP or health visitor if your child eats very few foods, is losing weight or not growing as expected, gags or is distressed at meals, or if whole food groups are refused for a long time.

This guide is general information, not medical advice. If your child has allergies, a medical condition or specific nutritional needs, follow the guidance of your GP, health visitor, dietitian or allergy specialist.

Common questions

Should I make my child a separate meal if they won't eat dinner?

Try not to. Make sure the family meal includes at least one safe food they usually eat, and let them fill up on that if they choose. If they eat little, offer the next planned meal or snack at its usual time rather than a replacement dinner.

How many times does a child need to try a new food?

It varies a lot between children, and many need to see and taste a food many times before they accept it. Keep offering small amounts without pressure, and do not give up after one or two refusals.

Is it OK to hide vegetables in food?

Blending vegetables into sauces is fine for adding variety, but it works best alongside, not instead of, offering vegetables your child can see. Children learn to accept foods by seeing and tasting them, so keep visible vegetables on the table too.

Should I reward my child for eating vegetables?

Rewards, especially pudding for finishing a plate, can make vegetables feel like a chore and sweets feel like a prize. Most feeding approaches suggest keeping pudding separate from what was eaten, and keeping mealtime talk neutral.

What if my picky eater only eats beige food?

Many young children prefer plain, pale foods such as pasta, bread and chips. Keep one of those on the table as the safe food, and offer small amounts of other foods next to it. If the range of foods is very narrow or shrinking, speak to your GP or health visitor.